Come See the 7 Talented Actresses Battling It Out for Starring Roles in the New 'Harry Potter' Spinoff

Can we keep them all?
Image may contain Coat Clothing Apparel Sunglasses Accessories Accessory Dakota Fanning Human Person and Kate Upton
Photos: Dominique Charriau/WireImage, Fred Duval/FilmMagic

We were pretty excited when we found out Eddie Redmayne would be starring as Newt Scamander in J.K. Rowling’s upcoming Harry Potter spinoff Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, but now the parts of two female leads need to be filled. And there are a whole lot of crazy-good options.

According to The Wrap, Warner Bros. and the director of the film have narrowed down the actresses to seven: four are up for the role of Tina, and the other three are being looked at for the role of Queenie. After seeing the list of big names and familiar faces, we don’t envy whoever has to make the final pick.

So who could you see starring alongside Eddie? Here’s where we’re at so far.

Tina:

Saoirse Ronan, Stockholm, Pennsylvania

Image may contain Saoirse Ronan Face Human Person Photo Portrait and Photography

Dakota Fanning, Very Good Girls

Image may contain Face Human Person Blonde Teen Kid Child Head Clothing and Apparel

Lili Simmons, Banshee

Image may contain Human Person Clothing and Apparel

Alison Sudol, Guapas

Image may contain Human Person Home Decor Head Clothing and Apparel

Queenie:

Kate Upton, The Other Woman

Image may contain Kate Upton Face Human Person Teen Blonde Kid and Child

Katherine Waterston, Inherent Vice

Image may contain Hat Clothing Apparel Human Person and Animal

Elizabeth Debicki, The Great Gatsby

Image may contain Human Person and Face

Told you this was tough. The first of three films already comes out November 2016, so we’ll definitely find out who the new stars will be soon.

Related:

Say Hello to the Star of That Must-See ’Harry Potter’ Spinoff

J.K. Rowling Is Really, Really Sorry for Killing This ’Harry Potter’ Favorite

See the First Pic from Daniel Radcliffe’s New Movie