Rosé ‘Rosie’ Album Review: Intimate Journey From BLACKPINK's Rosé to Just Rosie

Find out what the Teen Vogue group chat had to say about Rosé's first solo album.
Ros for new album Rosie with text overlay for group chat
Photo by Kenneth Capello. Art treatment by Liz Coulbourn

It's here: Rosé has finally released her first solo album, rosie, an intimate look into the end of a relationship and how she processed it over the past few years.

Rosie comes after years of Rosé's success as part of the K-pop girl group BLACKPINK — alongside Jennie, Lisa, and Jisoo — one of the most successful groups of the past decade. The 27-year-old New Zealand singer had previously explored her solo sound with a pair of songs in 2021, “On the Ground” and “Gone," showing a love for power ballads and acoustic guitars. Leading up to the album, Rosé released her biggest solo song yet, “APT” with Bruno Mars, which has so far spent six weeks at no. 1 on the Billboard Global 200.



There's a memorable scene in the BLACKPINK: Light Up the Sky Netflix documentary from a few years ago, when Rosé sits on the floor in a dance studio, playing guitar and singing to herself at night. “I have a hard time falling asleep. I have a lot of thoughts running through my head. Singing is kind of like stress relief. Everything kinda makes sense when I'm doing this.” Those feelings are clear on rosie, a cathartic album that isn't afraid to delve into her insecurities and fears around a sometimes toxic relationship.

Below, Teen Vogue editors P. Claire Dodson, Sara Delgado, Donya Momenian, and Aiyana Ishmael listened through Rosé's debut album rosie, chatting through her career up to this point with BLACKPINK and how she's exploring her own voice.


P. Claire Dodson, Assoc. Culture Director: so how are we all feeling about this rosé album?

Aiyana Ishmael, Associate Editor: Outside of BLACKPINK I have not heard a single thing about this lady so I feel I am going to be a very unbiased listener to her music haha.

Claire: lmao aiyana

Sara Delgado, Editor-at-Large: I am just ready for the breakup anthems

Claire: I'm a blackpink fan and rosé has always been my bias, so i'm really interested to see how this goes.... I loved "on the ground" so much

Sara: oh, yes, you were such a fan of “On the Ground” — i’m hoping she deviates a little from that sound here

Sara: we need a more mature version of Rosé!

Donya Momenian, Fashion & Beauty Associate Editor: i liked apt so much so i have high hopes

Aiyana: Three K-pop stans and Aiyana walk into a listening party

Claire: HA

Sara: aiyana, get ready lol

Donya: hoping for a secret emo kid banger

Claire: that feels likely

Donya: her december cover is so good

Sara: shall we hit play? are we all sonically and emotionally ready?

Aiyana: I'm excited!!

“number one girl”

Claire: I love “sweetheart of your city”

Sara: this song has been out for a minute, and i have to admit i liked it from the getgo but it has really grown on me even more

Aiyana: Okay I had no expectations going in but I already relate to her omg that's sister

Sara: i love a simple piano arrangement

Donya: it's a yes from me

Sara: Aiyana’s therapy session is open

Claire: it's an interesting album opener for sure, operates in that “we can't be friends” realm of “is this song about a person or the fans?”

Sara: so right

Donya: was on the fence but the chorus got me

Sara: she’s setting the tone

Aiyana: I'm a lover girl at heart so anything in this realm will have me becoming a Rosé fan

Claire: she's such a lover girl

Sara: letting us know she’s vulnerable and not just a super star

Sara: that “tell me … that i’m enough” and “i need it and don’t know why”

Claire: it hurts

Aiyana: This should be in a YA coming of age story where the main character is a dancer and she's professing her love through movement

Aiyana: Someone call Netflix right now

Sara: you are so right… it’s giving TATB soundtrack

Claire: she sounds so good live doing this song too

Sara: the airy top notes

Sara: her trademark

Claire: reallly good showcase for her voice

Aiyana: Starting an album with a ballad is bold. I like it

Aiyana: Sets the tone

Sara: the production getting much more anthemic as she explodes

Donya: would love this as a kid sitting in the back of my mom's mini van staring out the rainy window

Sara: and we dont even notice

Sara: love how it presents her in a new light — she’s not BLACKPINK’s Rosé, she’s just Rosie here

Claire: laid bare

Sara: yup, same struggles as everyone else

Sara: also sonically, it’s just her bread and butter but stripped down and elevated

“3am”

Sara: lol this opening line

Aiyana: She's so me "just saw a red flag going to pretend I didn't see that"

Donya: too real. so true bestie

Sara: rosie :handshake::skin-tone-3: sza

Aiyana: Okay this is a fun beat

Sara: oh i love this tone

Aiyana: It's very summer, skateboarding hanging with friends

Claire: have to be honest this is sort of getting into ed sheeran territory...

Aiyana: LOL. Not my fave ginger omg

Sara: aiyana the visuals for the album are at a skatepark

Aiyana: OMG

Sara: you sure you don’t stan already?

Aiyana: Let me lock in

Sara: hahah claire, it’s the strums

Aiyana: It also has an early 2000s sound to it. I wonder who produced!

Claire: Producers were Jake Weinberg (Zach Bryan, quinnie) and Ojivolta (Kanye West, Lil Nas X, also did Rosé's “On the Ground”)

Sara: it’s giving avril for me, but poppier

Claire: def a bit of avril!

Aiyana: Very Avril. I need to listen to this song the way God intended: driving my car in the suburbs with the windows down

Donya: exactly

Sara: exactly. it’s giving late summer

Claire: breezy

Donya: this would have been a summer bop

two years

Claire: this is taylor-y

Aiyana: Why this sound like TS

Claire: jack antonoff did you sneak in here

Claire: getaway car vibe

Sara: the change feels so ominous

Donya: i liked the enunciation on chemical there

Aiyana: This switch from first two feel different

Sara: love this vocal layering, oddly inhuman

Aiyana: Kinda like the first two tracks are sisters and this is a cousin

Claire: “even had a funeral for you in my head”... yes

Sara: lol i was thinking this was very antonoff coded too

Aiyana: Sorry to the stans this is not my favorite

Donya: i feel like this would be on the breaking dawn soundtrack

Donya: interpret that how you will, to each their own

Aiyana: I am new to my girl but this doesn't feel like what she gave me in the first two tracks. If I had to hear this song first I wouldn't be tempted to keep listening to her. But also maybe because it does sound like a scrapped Taylor Song even vocally

Sara: this is def slower, not my cup of tea precisely but it has its audience

Claire: i'm a sucker for a synth

Sara: this is more “on the ground” coded

Claire: yes!!

Sara: so more og rosé i’d say

Donya: i cant move on either bestie

Sara: gotta keep a little of the old you

Sara: the synths did indeed eat

Donya: i have high hopes for this one

“toxic till the end”

Claire: toxic till the end ! spacey vibe

Aiyana: Needed this album lowkey senior year of high school

Sara: this feels like a more natural progression from the previous song. again very ’00s, YA

Aiyana: I prefer this over 2 Year

Sara: “i present to you the ex." in case there were any doubts

Claire: it made me blush a little… spoken word stuff in songs is tough for me

Aiyana: Y'all who is she singing about lol. Who broke her heart

Donya: so manipulating part is very satisfying

Sara: it’s effective

Sara: the million dollar question

Aiyana: The art of talking on the track is a skill that takes a lot of work

Sara: this was very taylor swift-coded at the beginning and now it’s very olivia rodrigo-coded

"drinks or coffee"

Aiyana: Why I'm dancing in my seat

Sara: immediately yes

Aiyana: Okay Miss Girl

Claire: little afrobeat moment

Donya: oh this is more fun

Sara: this bubbly beat — the way she blends the vocals to the beat change is tickling my brain

Claire: agreeeed

Donya: yes that was great

Sara: i wish we could hear less of her gasps for air to keep the composition cleaner, but i really like this

Aiyana: NGL I am eating it up

"APT." feat. Bruno Mars

Claire: apt time

Sara: SOTY!

Claire: seconded!

Aiyana: She likes to talk on the track

Aiyana: I KNOW THIS SONG

Claire: in this one it's really working

Sara: just picture me chanting

Donya: love absolutely love

Sara: kissy face kissy face

Sara: it’s so visual this song

Sara: and so engaging

Aiyana: I love this song it's a hit

Sara: like talk about a perfect formula

Claire: obviously draws on some 2000s vibes & the ting tings etc but feels very fresh

Sara: right it’s familiar but with a twist

Claire: good addition to karaoke duet canon

Sara: the layering of bruno’s “whatevers” is underrated

Donya: "just meet me at the" part feels so perfect every time

Claire: i love them collaborating together. genius

Aiyana: I wonder what is her favorite Bruno Mars song is that made her want to work with him

Claire: I think she said she went to his concert and realized she knew and loved every song

“gameboy”

Aiyana: I love the sound of this already

Sara: ok ’00s

Aiyana: A little r&b feel

Sara: cry me a river girl version

Claire: no exactly

Donya: OOOOOOOOOOOH

Aiyana: Oh yeah I love this track. It's smooth

Donya: get him girl

Sara: this is playful

Sara: the repetition of “break”

Donya: this song is perf for a grwm after the end of a situationship

Sara: this guitar base is saur good, it’s for the ’90s kids

Aiyana: Someone needs to investigate. I need a 5,000 word essay on who she is talking about in all of these songs. That person needs to be identified.

Sara: speak your truth, D

Donya: when you pull off your most perfect makeup look

Aiyana: The beauty girls get it

Donya: thats why her makeup is always so good, she knows heartbreak

Aiyana: This to me will be in my top three I feel confidently about it.

Sara: same

Sara: though i wish it was more r&b towards the end

"stay a little longer"

Claire: more pretty piano

Claire: love it

Aiyana: I am a sucker for an emosh ballad

Aiyana: She will win me over with all of these

Sara: at a bar after a breakup piano to be exact

Sara: ok her voice sounds so different here

Aiyana: I like the pain in her voice. it really adds to the song and makes it feel a bit more real

Sara: the controlled strains, they really aid the message, yes

Aiyana: NGL she vocally has an interesting range. i feel like without knowing you might question if these are all the same people

Donya: it's so captivating

Donya: similar feeling as listening to brothers osborne

Claire: fascinating reference donya

Sara: she’s definitely leaning into the alto more in this one and i’m not mad!

Donya: very moving

Sara: donya, elaborate

Donya: i feel a lot of feelings rn

Aiyana: Need the research paper, Donya

“not the same”

Sara: “not the same” and quite literally

Aiyana: This sounds like someone

Donya: and really strong voices

Sara: because this is so different

Aiyana: Cannot pinpoint but it sounds like someone

Claire: is it... camp rock?

Claire: demi

Aiyana: LMAO

Sara: oh this melody is very familiar

Aiyana: Yes DEMI omg

Claire: demi tones

Sara: OMG SHE DOES SOUND LIKE CAMP ROCK DEMI

Aiyana: Movie one Demi

Aiyana: Scrapped song from the award-winning movie Camp Rock

Donya: so she's kind of a music chameleon

Aiyana: Chameleon is perfect word

Donya: she needs to do the jimmy fallon impersonation wheel thing

Claire: album is a collage of the mid 2000s to mid 2010s

Aiyana: I think that's also very fun for her first solo album

Sara: i love the arpeggios in the background

Aiyana: Play around with sounds and see what sticks like spaghetti on the wall

Sara: sucker for a guitar

Donya: she said the f word! how fun!

Donya: i like the contrast of her voice and the music

Aiyana: I actually really like this song

Claire: me too

Sara: the ending

Aiyana: Not the ending

“call it the end”

Sara: she said “enough fun”

Aiyana: She said new sound b*tches! (edited)

Claire: she sort of is bringing a country singer sensibility to a lot of these

Sara: “the one or the one that got away”

Donya: wait not to go back but it reminded me of brothers osborne because they are both called stay a little longer

Aiyana: She made this for the girlies who cannot make up their mind

Sara: ouch

Donya: silly me

Sara: this one is very country vocally, claire

Sara: i love the juxtaposition with the more simple compositions

Claire: if you went in expecting this album to be like APT you might be surprised lol, but I think her voice is so unique and pretty and dexterous that it's working even when it's sad for long periods

Sara: this and “number one girl” just relying mainly on piano and the voice

Sara: they could be so much different had she gone for a full arrangement

Donya: listen to this after “his car isnt yours” by wendy and just cry it all out besties

“too bad for us”

Sara: “APT.” was the sprinkle of fun, and the rest is pen and paper

Sara: i love the guitar with the voice there, the mirrored progressions

Sara: a different type of fun

Donya: ROSES?

Sara: “the roses don’t grow here”

Sara: loaded

Donya: i liked the chorus a lot

Donya: made my head bob

Claire: pretty strings

Claire: this little cinematic backing

Claire: verging on movie trailer

Donya: the way she sings "disappear"  and "here" is so nice

Aiyana: Ngl this not doing anything for me but it's cute

Sara: i truly appreciate how bold she’s being about just not being sure of things — feeling conflicted and even contradicting herself. it’s so refreshing for any pop star, but especially coming from the k-pop scene

Claire: great point!

Sara: the little cinematic verse you mentioned

Sara: it’s reminding me of “P.S I Love You”

Donya: i think this is one of her better bridges

Sara: this song feels like an irish cliff, i can’t explain it

“dance all night”

Claire: final track!

Sara: ok this is fun again

Sara: this melody is also very familiar!!!!

Claire: this is maybe the one nostalgia-y one that isn't tracking for me.... it feels like song that plays during a wedding reception in a movie

Sara: like at the very end?

Sara: freaky friday style?

Claire: it's sort of trying to be 70s but with that very 2010 approach

Aiyana: It also gives transitional scene in a movie where she's trying on different looks for a big event

Sara: i feel like it’s a bit to chill for that

Donya: the end of freaky friday? the ultimate?

Sara: but it’s definitely giving credit song

Aiyana: Interesting way to end an album

Donya: i loved the ultimate

Claire: I love a lot of what she's doing on rosie but this one is a bit of a lackluster ending to an album

Claire: that is otherwise compelling

Aiyana: I am intrigued by her

Sara: i guess it works to signal that we need to leave

Aiyana: She is a musical enigma to me as a newer listener

Donya: i feel like maybe to end on not very sad girl vibes

Donya: a little pick yourself up and dance all night

Donya: wait that's it? ... so no emo banger? :woman_standing::skin-tone-2:

Sara: there is one hidden track in her vinyl, i wonder if that one would bridge this for a more cohesive bow

Aiyana: I honestly would've preferred a sad girl ending

Claire: love her voice, I will definitely keep listening to this... some really interesting parts and also some that aren't hitting as hard

Claire: is that vampirehollie @sara

Sara: yes!

Aiyana: I think it'll be a strong start to her solo career and I am excited to see where she lands with finding her sound

Donya: maybe the emo song was the friends we made along the way

Sara: there’s def some emo

Claire: agreed. she can do a lot! so it'll be more a matter of what her eventual vibe wants to be

Sara: but it’s more heartbreak-tinged

Donya: yeah late 2010s emo

Claire: it's also hard because APT. is so so good

Claire: so it sets a high bar and then the rest of the album doesn't feel quite as exciting

Sara: i really want to see what she uses as inspo later down the line — a breakup can only last you so much and she’s said the album was the way to let go. i’d love to see her to take on a conceptual album.

Sara: “APT.” is definitely the star

Sara: should we do a quick top 3 for everyone?

Claire: I'm rooting for her! Excited to see where she goes from here

Aiyana: “a breakup can only last you so much”

Aiyana: Taylor is calling

Claire: top 3..... “APT.,” “number one girl,” “two years”

Sara: i think mine are “APT.” "gameboy,” and “drinks or coffee”

Sara: “number one girl” is def up there too

Claire: i do like drinks or coffee and think that'll be a hit

Claire: i don't love that outro though… we get it!!! you'll get drinks or coffee!

Sara: it loses steam but the beginning is too good

Aiyana: Top Three: gameboy, number one girl, and drinks or coffee

Donya: my top 3 are APT, gameboy, and stay a little longer (brothers osborne's sister)

Aiyana: Honorable mention is the Ed Sheeran banger: 3am

Sara: ok a lot of overlap!

Sara: “toxic till the end” will grow on me, i fear

Claire: agreed

Aiyana: The beginning half of the album is the stronger portion, in my opinion

Donya: i liked toxic til the end too

Donya: i think she should make an emo version of toxic til the end

Donya: it could go with some finger pointing

Claire: good idea

Sara: any final thoughts?

Donya: just excited to see her solo career flourish and grow!

Sara: i think it’s a pretty solid introduction — not every song can be a massive hit but it’s cohesive sonically and lyrically. it’s so hard when expectations are so high but i’m excited to see her play with sounds even more

Claire: and in the meantime, i want to sing some of these at karaoke asap